HONUS WAGNER PRESENTATION WATCH APPRAISAL

-
In the October 14th, 2016 edition of the Detroit News, there was an appraisal done by DuMouchelles Auction Gallery in Detroit for a 1930's era Bulova Presentation Wristwatch. The inscription reads "To Honus Wagner From the Boys of Greenwich Village". 
The history of the wristwatch is unknown to the owner and was not found by the appraiser. 
Hall of Famer Wagner retired as a player in 1917. He was a coach for the Pittsburgh Pirates during the 1930's and there appeared to be no known link to Greenwich Village (New York). 
I believe I may have the watches' origin.
The Huron Baseball Club of Greenwich Village planned and held a "Honus Wagner Day" at The New York Giants' Polo Grounds in New York on May 22, 1938. Apparently, Wagner had done a favor for the baseball club at some time and they were staging a day for the ex fellow National Leaguer on the first visit of the Pittsburgh Pirates to the Polo Grounds in 1938. The arrangement committee included: John J Quinn Chairman; Jimmy Walker, former Mayor of New York; Sheriff Finn; Jack LaRocca, Pitcher of the New York Yankees; Mike Meola, pitcher of the Toronto Club, Gene Tunney, Former Heavyweight Boxing Champion; Jimmy Powers, New York Daily News; Hugh Bradley, New York Evening Post; Thomas Lynch, M. Murphy, Harold Neary and others. So, it was no small affair. 
It is completely plausible that the presentation wristwatch in this article was given to Wagner by the "Boys of Greenwich Village" during "Honus Wagner Day"
DuMouchelles appraised the wristwatch at $1,000-2,000 and up and I agree with this figure. Wagner items AFTER his playing days are not as desirable as playing day collectibles. The wristwatch is also not given by a major league entity (Such as from the Pittsburgh Pirates or the Baseball Hall of Fame). However, a personal item potentially owned by the Hall of Famer will be desirable to Wagner collectors. NOTE: Without true provenance, there will be some trepidation from potential buyers/bidders.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Denkert Signature Model Baseball Gloves - Ultimate Resource

-
Image
Denkert Sporting Goods Company made signature model baseball gloves from the 1920's thru the 1960's out of Johnstown and Gloversville, NY. I have compiled a listing of over 544 player-endorsed glove models manufactured by Denkert. Their Pro Master, Pro Maker and Sure Trap models were also made for private brands  It would only make sense that being located in New York, Denkert would have a Mickey Mantle endorsement. In fact, 24 different Mantle models have been discovered, including exclusive store models. Denkert did not get a lot of endorsements from other major stars, but, seemed to sign contracts with minor stars such as Pee Wee Reese, Al Rosen, Phil Rizzuto, Bill Skowron (18 known models), Bobby Richardson and Red Schoendienst. Reese was a favorite, having no less than 25 different model numbers over the years. They also got endorsements from more common players than most other glove makers such as Vic Wertz, Danny O'Connell, Del Rice, Jim Landis, Chet La
Read more

STARKIE'S JOLLY NIGGER BANK - ORIGINAL IDENTIFIED v. OLD REPRODUCTION

-
In the process of liquidating a living estate, we came upon a rare and original Starkie's Jolly Nigger (Moves Ears) Mechanical Bank. The bank was patented in 1920 by Robert Eastwood Starkie of Burnley, England (British Pat No 152,588). All known banks were made of Aluminum. In 1945, a patent was issued to Robert Patterson Starkie for a similar bank. This is the bank that is most often seen in Antique and Collectible circles and is often mistaken for the original from 1920, even by major auction houses. At first glance from the front, the banks look identical. However, there are at least 8 differences: 1) Original: Ears are located closer to the eyes. A "V" shaped section from the back half of the casting fits into a "V" groove in the front half. Later Version: Ears are located in the middle of the castings. 2) Original: Back has the inscription: "Starkie's Pat No 152,588" Later Version: Blank back. 3) Original: Base plate has circular holes and is
Read more